Now Open in Bayport

Ready to find
the card
you've been hunting
for?

From rookie parallels to vintage gems — we stock what collectors actually want. Stop scrolling and start collecting at Bayport's most trusted card shop.

Explore Inventory Visit Our Shop
Locally trusted
Bayport, NY
Sports card collection
Rookie Parallel
Limited Edition
Vintage sports card
Vintage Gem
Graded & Protected
Collectible cards
Graded Slabs
PSA / BGS Accepted
10,000+
Cards in Stock
Same Day
Grading Submissions
Scroll
Top Brands: Upper Deck · Panini · Topps · Bowman · Donruss Grading: PSA · BGS · SGC · CCG Sports: NFL · NBA · MLB · NHL · Soccer · UFC · F1 Bayport's Home for Collectors Since Day One Top Brands: Upper Deck · Panini · Topps · Bowman · Donruss Grading: PSA · BGS · SGC · CCG Sports: NFL · NBA · MLB · NHL · Soccer · UFC · F1 Bayport's Home for Collectors Since Day One
What We Carry

Inventory That Moves

Whether you're breaking wax or building a lifetime collection, we've got the product you're looking for — and the knowledge to help you find it.

Trading Cards

Base sets, parallels, inserts, and autographs across all major sports. New product drops weekly.

NFL NBA MLB NHL

Graded Cards

PSA, BGS, SGC — we buy, sell, and submit. Slabs from budget-friendly to investment-grade.

PSA BGS SGC

Boxes & Sets

Retail boxes, case breaks, and complete set breaks. Hit or miss — that's the thrill.

Blasters Retail Case

Single Cards

Search our inventory by player, team, or set. We price competitively and negotiate fairly.

Rookies Autographs Parallel

Non-Sports Cards

Pokémon, One Piece, Magic, Yu-Gi-Oh, and more. We carry product for every collector.

Pokémon Magic Anime

Supplies & Accessories

Top loaders, penny sleeves, magnums, binders, display cases — everything to protect your collection.

Sleeves Packs Display
First Choice Sports Cards interior
Community
First Priority
Our Story

More Than a Card Shop — A Hub

First Choice Sports Cards & Collectibles started with one simple belief: every collector deserves a place where they can find what they're looking for without the hassle.

Located right on Montauk Highway in Bayport, we've built a reputation on honest pricing, real product, and a team that actually plays the games and follows the seasons. You won't find pushy sales tactics here — just people who love this hobby as much as you do.

Whether you're picking up your first pack or your thousandth slab, we treat every visit the same way: with respect, expertise, and a genuine interest in helping you find exactly what you want.

100%
Authentic Product
Local
Bayport-Based
All
Sports Covered
Grading
Submission Service
Beyond the Counter

What Makes Us Different

We're not just a retail space — we're part of the collecting community on Long Island.

Grading Submissions

Send your raw cards through us for PSA, BGS, or SGC grading. We handle the paperwork and shipping so you don't have to.

Buy & Sell

Got singles or lots you want to move? We offer fair market value for quality inventory. Bring it in and get a real offer.

Box Breaks

Join us for live box breaks — pick your team, watch the hits come flying, and walk away with the cards you actually want.

Expert Advice

Not sure where to start? Our team will help you build a collection that fits your budget and your goals — no gatekeeping.

Ready to Make Your Next Big Hit?

Stop dreaming about that card and go get it. Swing by the shop, give us a call, or send us an email — we're always happy to help.

Get Directions Call (631) 472-0250
Find Us

Visit First Choice

We're conveniently located on Montauk Highway in the heart of Bayport. Pull in, browse, and say hello.

Address

749 Montauk Hwy
Bayport, NY 11705-1609

Phone

(631) 472-0250

Call or text — we're always happy to chat

Email

carlycool@aol.com

For inquiries, consignment, and bulk orders

Is this your business?This is my business